Found on the deployment machine on 2026-10-11, the first time `hhstream-live` was run **as a unit** rather than from a login shell: a systemd unit's PATH has no system profile, so the capture command `grim` is not found, ten times, and the stream gives up. It answers on its port, serves the landing page and reports `"stopped": true, "failures": 10` while showing nothing -- the quiet half of the failure is what makes it worth a file. The module already solves this for `sessions.apps` by requiring an absolute store path; the stream's unit has to do the same (or set PATH, which is what made the deployment run work). Recorded in `docs/TODO/` with the two fixes, and named as a risk on stage 3 of the plan, which is the stage that turns this from an experiment into the only path.
12 KiB
Plan — a session-stream webapp (one port, a router, a phrase per session)
Supersedes docs/plans/2026-10-03-network-stream.md (call it v1). v1 spread a
listener over a port range and handed each session a 128-bit URL token;
the operator asked for the opposite shape: one port, a router with a page per
session, and a spoken phrase to open each one, with a stream existing only
for the sessions it was enabled on. Everything v1 says about the capture
path and the separate unit still holds and is not repeated here; this file
replaces §2–§4 of v1 and keeps its §1 (transport) and §6 stages in spirit.
Decisions below are the ones worth disagreeing with. Nothing is built yet — the branch carries only a plan.
1. What is new, and why
| v1 | Now | Why |
|---|---|---|
Lowest free port in 9120–9131, one per session |
One port, default 9988, shared by every stream | A phrase is easier to read out when there is one address, not one per session. One listener is also one thing to firewall and one thing to stop. |
/<token>/…, a secrets.token_urlsafe blob |
/<phrase>/…, four words off a fixed list |
A URL a person can say out loud and retype on a phone. Same job as the token — it is the only credential — but shaped for a human. Entropy is discussed in §4. |
stream start on any live session |
stream enable on a session, remembered, default off |
"Not on for all sessions at all times": a session does not stream because it exists; it streams because it was switched on. |
| Pages are token routes under one session's listener | A router: an index, and four routes per session (viewer, stream, snapshot, status) | A small app, not a file dump: / lists what is on, /<phrase>/ is the thing you watch. |
The transport is unchanged: MJPEG over HTTP (multipart/x-mixed-replace),
the JPEG grim already produces (-c -t jpeg -q 80 -), 5 fps default, hard cap
10, capture only while a viewer is connected. A still browser <img> is the
whole client. No WebSocket, no HLS, no TLS in this slice.
2. The unit, and the port
hhstream-live.service, one process, exactly as v1 argued: an executor
beside the pointer driver, not the frame server (whose one-socket contract must
not grow a LAN parser) and not the broker (grim blocks tens to hundreds of ms
and must not stall touch/kill). It runs as the compositor user hhstream,
finds WAYLAND_DISPLAY the way hyprland-headless-stream does, does not
take RuntimeDirectory=/run/hhstream (that would delete the broker's socket),
and speaks newline-JSON to the broker on /run/hhstream/live.sock.
It owns the port. A single listener means no allocator, no TIME_WAIT
dance, and one URL prefix. The port is a module option (sessions.stream.port,
default 9988); the unit binds sessions.stream.bind (default 127.0.0.1).
If the port is taken the unit fails loudly and says so — it does not hunt for
another one, because a stream at a port nobody was told is worse than a stream
that is down.
Bind and firewall defaults stay closed. openFirewall defaults false; the
module adds no networking.firewall.allowedTCPPorts unless it is set. Until
that opt-in, the phone path is ssh -L 9988:127.0.0.1:9988 from the device.
3. The router
One handler, four shapes, phrase-keyed. Everything else is a 404 with an
empty body; a wrong phrase is never echoed back.
GET / index: the enabled streams, their names, viewer
counts, and links into them
GET /<phrase>/ the viewer page — an <img src="stream.mjpg">
in a dark frame with the session's name
GET /<phrase>/stream.mjpg the multipart/x-mixed-replace stream
GET /<phrase>/frame.jpg the most recent single JPEG (snapshot)
GET /<phrase>/status.json {session, output, fps, viewers, last_frame_age_s}
- The phrase is matched case-insensitively and tolerates a missing trailing slash, because a person will type it by hand; it is stored lowercase.
- The root page is a form, never a list. The phrase is the password to a
stream and is known only by whoever enabled it, so
/must not enumerate sessions or leak phrases: it is a box you type a phrase into, which forwards to/<phrase>/./<phrase>/…always works from whatever the bind allows. - The pages are built-in — one small HTML/CSS/JS string in the package, no CDN, no framework, no extra Python dependency. "Webapp" here means a real router and legible pages, not a build step.
- Multiple pages per session output: a session's output
hh-<id>gets its own four routes; adding a session adds routes under its phrase, never a new port. - Wrong-phrase lookups are rate-limited (a small per-IP counter, ~20/min) so the phrase is not enumerable at line speed over the LAN.
4. The phrase
Generated when the stream is first enabled for a session, and kept in the session record so it survives a broker restart and a re-enable.
- Shape:
<word>-<word>-<word>-<word>-<xxxxx>, e.g.amber-otter-lantern-harbor-7k2qp. - Words come from a vendored EFF large wordlist (7776 lines, ~70 KB, in the
repo — no network at runtime, no dependency) and the tail is five characters
of
[a-z0-9]. Four of those lines are hyphenated (drop-down,felt-tip,t-shirt,yo-yo) and are dropped on load, because a hyphen is the phrase's own separator and such a word would make a six-token phrase nobody could hear the shape of; 7772 words are usable. Four words is4 · log2(7772) ≈ 51.7bits and the tail adds5 · log2(36) ≈ 25.8, for ≈ 77.5 bits — comfortably past anything a LAN request rate can enumerate, and the operator's stated shape ("5 with a random 5 character string for the last word"). --phraseon enable sets your own, and it is held to exactly the generated shape (four[a-z]{3,}words plus a five-character[a-z0-9]tail): the phrase is the stream's only credential, so anything a--phrasemay be is a password an operator can choose, and a looser check would accepta-b-c.disablethenenablerotates it. A rotation is one record write.- The phrase is the only credential. It is in the URL, in cleartext on the LAN when the LAN is opted into — the threat model is "another device on the LAN can watch if it can guess the phrase", not "the phrase is hidden from the network". Stated plainly so nobody mistakes it for TLS.
- Secrets discipline from v1 carries over: the audit log records session id, output, port and bind; it never records the phrase.
5. Enable / disable, and the idle clock
Only an enabled session has a phrase, a listener entry, and any capture at all. Enabling is an explicit act, remembered in the record:
hhstream session stream enable <id> [--phrase PHRASE] [--fps N]
hhstream session stream disable <id>
hhstream session stream list # enabled streams, phrases, viewers
hhstream session stream status [id]
enablerequires the session to have a container output (hh-<id>); without one it is the existingno_containererror (exit 10). A stream never falls back to the main output — that would put every other session on the phone.enableprints only the URL on stdout (http://127.0.0.1:9988/<phrase>/); stderr names the output and prints thedisablecommand.--jsonaddsurl,phrase,output,fps,viewers. Re-enabling while enabled returns the same phrase;--phrasemismatch isstream_busy(exit 8).- No new exit numbers: reuse 2 (bad port/fps), 6 (
stream_budget— the module's per-process viewer cap), 8 (busy), 10 (stream_unavailable/no container). enable,disable,list,statusdo not touch the idle clock — the same rule aspointer.*. A connected viewer is activity: about once a minute the broker asks the daemon for viewer counts and stampstouchwhen any is non-zero. That is the one new way the clock moves; it is what keeps a session the operator is watching on his phone from being reaped at three hours. An enabled stream with nobody watching runs nogrimand keeps no session alive.- The session record gains
stream = {enabled, phrase, fps, viewers, port}(ornull). Registry schema 3 → 4; older records migrate tostream: nulland are adopted, not refused. - Teardown order is v1's and it is load-bearing:
disablethe stream (close the listener, drop the route) beforehyprctl output remove.
6. Restart behaviour
A broker restart does not invent listeners. If hhstream-live is still up,
the broker asks it for the list and re-attaches them to the session records, so
status and teardown still see them. If the daemon restarted too, the enabled
records keep their phrases but the streams are off until re-enabled — an open
port and a running capture are explicit acts, and the phrase is not a licence to
capture without one.
7. What to build, in what order
| Stage | What | Size | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Contract text: docs/CONTRACT-sessions.md → sessions-v3 (the four verbs, /run/hhstream/live.sock, hhstream-live, the single port, the viewer-touch exception, schema 4, error names). |
S | Freezing the wrong default. This plan is the review. |
| 1 | hhstream-live: the HTTP server, the router, the phrase (wordlist + generator), one output, injected capture, unit tests. No broker. |
M | A phone that will not paint multipart/x-mixed-replace; the index leaking phrases when made public. |
| 2 | Broker + CLI: the record field, schema 4, the four verbs, teardown order, viewer heartbeat, integration test on 127.0.0.1. |
L | A second capture on re-enable; disable racing output remove; a heartbeat that keeps a session alive with zero viewers. |
| 3 | Module: the unit, /run/hhstream/live.sock, port 9988, bind loopback, fps 5/cap 10, enable false, openFirewall false, publicIndex false. No host firewall edit here. |
M | A second RuntimeDirectory on /run/hhstream deleting control.sock; and the capture binary — a unit's PATH has no grim, so the stream serves an empty frame area without saying why (docs/TODO/capture-binary-and-the-unit-path.md). |
| 4 | Host pass: enable a real session, open the URL in the machine's own Chromium, confirm pixels change without a reload; write down what was on screen. | S | An empty container looking like a broken stream. Confirm the window is on hh-<id> first. |
Test layers are v1's: tests/unit for the HTTP/router/phrase with a fake
capture (multipart framing, each route, wrong phrase → empty 404, rate limit,
capture idle at zero viewers, "unknown output" ends the stream), tests/sessions
for the verbs and the clock, one integration test that runs a real daemon and a
real hhstream-live on loopback with urllib reading two JPEGs. VM checks stay
one at a time; no browser in a VM check.
8. Decisions taken (2026-10-04)
- The root page is a form, never a list. The phrase is a password; the index must not hand it out. (Was "loopback-only index".)
- Phrase = four EFF-large words + a five-character base-36 tail (~77.5 bits). The tail is what the operator asked for in place of a fifth word.
- Port 9988, fixed and single, no range fallback.
- Capture pauses at zero viewers (v1's choice, kept).
Stage 1 is built (src/hhstream_live/, tests/live/, 51 unit tests): the
router, the pages, the phrase and the publisher, runnable standalone via
hhstream-live serve --stream PHRASE=OUTPUT. The broker verbs and
/run/hhstream/live.sock are Stage 2.
Stage 3 has started, out of order and on purpose (2026-10-11). A machine
had to be able to reach a stream before the rest of the app is settled: the
operator asked for the port to be open on the deployment machine, where the app
runs by hand, and a hand-written firewall line in one machine's config is the
wrong place for a fact about this flake. So sessions.stream { port, bind, openFirewall } and the single rule it stands for are in nix/module.nix, with
checks/vm-stream-firewall.nix asking the running firewall — and a peer
outside the guest — whether the configured port is the one that opened.
What that does not do: no unit, no phrases, no session stream enable|disable|list|status, and nothing in the module turns a stream on. The
app is still started by hand, and the option's whole job is to describe where a
stream will be reachable from.