The marker is now written up as the *open* item rather than a research note: it
is not implemented, the video went out without it, and everything else about the
pointer is exact and readable.
proof-video.py is rewritten for desks, one command, no arguments. It films the
session's own output with `record --output` instead of the published socket --
with desks, the socket carries every output stitched together, so a viewer would
watch two thirds wallpaper. The scrolling beats are real pointer axis events,
down twice and back up once, so the movement cannot be mistaken for a page that
merely loaded a different part of itself.
Closed: containers-do-not-bind and pointer-needs-a-container-or-a-screen. Both
were the same defect seen from two sides, and both are fixed by assigning
windows by pid -- two sessions now hold two outputs with a real browser on each,
and the pointer aims at a desk that has something in it.
The cursor item is rewritten with the answer rather than the speculation: the
compositor draws no cursor image for a virtual pointer, so no capture setting
can make one appear. The evidence is in the file, including the three wrong
answers that came before it and the boring measurement that settled it.
New item: killing a session left two browsers alive, found by counting windows
rather than sessions.
grim's `-c` ("include cursors in the screenshot") exists because the screencopy
protocol takes the decision from the client: Hyprland's capture_output carries
an overlayCursor argument and the frame is only composited with the cursor when
it is set. Without it a frame shows that *something* changed and never where it
was clicked -- and a click on the wrong element looks exactly like a click on
the right one, which is the whole reason the pointer work is verifiable at all.
Found by reading Hyprland's Screencopy.cpp rather than guessing at a compositor
setting: `no_hardware_cursors` was already on, and the cursor was invisible
because nobody had asked for it.
Two things stood between "containers enabled" and an application actually
sitting on its own output, and neither was where I said it was.
ipc: discovery refused whenever two instance directories existed, which every
compositor restart leaves behind (a log file where a live compositor used to
be). After two rebuilds the broker could not reach any compositor at all, so no
container could be created and the pointer had nothing to aim at. It now asks
each candidate for its version and uses the one that answers, preferring the
newest only when two answer, and still refusing when none do.
container_host.claim: windows are assigned by the pid the compositor already
reports, not by the class stamp the per-session rule matches -- foot, GTK, Qt
and the chromium wrapper all ignore that stamp, so the desk was created and
left empty while the window sat in special:quarantine. The claim moves the
window to its desk's workspace, makes that workspace the one the desk is
showing, and reads back: the record says where the window is, never where it
was sent. Called from both places a window can appear -- the read-back at start
and container.reconcile -- and skipped in the steady state, because a move is a
real change on screen and should not be dispatched for its own sake.
Found live while trying to demonstrate the scroll verb that was just deployed:
every cursor verb resolves its target through _pointer_output, which requires a
container output, and no session has one -- because containers are off. So the
verb exists and cannot be used, and the acceptance video's missing cursor was
never a capture artefact: nothing could have moved it.
Recorded with the routes out (aim at the shared output when a session owns no
container; or fix the binding first and leave this alone), the cost of the
quick one, and the misleading hint that blames the compositor for a switched-off
feature.
Item 1 said the broker reads none of the container or pointer configuration.
That was true and is not: the settings are parsed beside Policy and a switched-off
container host reports itself unavailable with the key named. The item now
records what actually matters about it -- that containers are off on the
deployment machine because no window can be put in one -- and the section links
docs/TODO/, where each open problem has its impact written down.
The TODO folder itself landed in the previous commit by accident (a `git add -A
docs` swept it in with the scroll work); this commit only makes it findable.
A session could move a cursor and press it, but not scroll. The protocol
already had the request -- zwlr_virtual_pointer_v1.axis(time, axis, value) --
it had simply never been implemented, in the driver or the broker.
hhstream session pointer scroll <id> --axis vertical --amount 3
Positive is down (vertical) or right (horizontal): the protocol's direction,
not a choice of ours, which is why direction travels in the sign and there is
deliberately no up/down vocabulary layered over it. The output is whatever the
last warp aimed at, exactly like a button, so scrolling somewhere else is a
warp first -- and the lease is what keeps the whole gesture atomic. Bounded at
100 wheel clicks per request on both sides, because a decimal-point slip should
be a refusal rather than a session scrolled somewhere unrecoverable.
The resume point is re-stamped, not moved: the cursor did not go anywhere, so
the coordinates are re-affirmed and only the stamp advances. Recorded in the
contract as an amendment to the frozen op set, because adding an op to a frozen
interface should be visible rather than implied.
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Driving the session's browser over CDP, then a terminal with cowsay, was a
scratch script twice and got pruned from scratch once -- which produced an
80-second video of an idle browser and no error. It is asked for repeatedly, so it
belongs with the rest of the agent-eyes tooling, takes a session id, and says in
its docstring that the URLs are real (the search uses key= singular, the bug that
once silently cost every Gunpost search its filtering).
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The module rendered containers_enabled, workspace_base, container_mode,
max_containers and the pointer lease keys into the TOML, and policy.py read only
[defaults] and [apps] -- so the settings were inert. The defaults coincided,
which made it look honoured, until a deployment tried to turn containers off and
found it could not.
Settings now come from the same file: parsed beside Policy (read by __main__, so
the manager keeps taking a plain ManagerConfig its tests build directly) and
carried into ContainerHost, which reports itself unavailable when switched off.
That is the whole mechanism -- the manager already treats an unavailable host as
'sessions without containers', which is what turning them off means -- and the
reason names the key, so a disabled machine cannot be mistaken for one whose
compositor is down.
This is what made the rollback on the host possible; the machine had containers
built, tested, and impossible to disable.
vm-pointer measured what this setting actually does: with follow_mouse=0 Hyprland
delivers pointer events only to the keyboard-focused window, so a click aimed at
0.25,0.75 of a session's container put the cursor at x=299 y=519 -- inside that
window -- and both clients reported nothing. The click was aimed correctly and
delivered nowhere.
The comment here said 'no pointer will ever exist; do not let focus depend on
one', which was true when written and is false now that the broker injects a
virtual pointer. The cursor lease already serialises input, so focus following
the pointer cannot make two sessions fight over the keyboard.
The surface the plan described, and the first composer of real compositor
evidence: seven checks green one at a time, including three new ones. They proved
`hyprctl output create headless` works (PLAN experiment 3, until now
unverified), that a click lands where it was aimed read from the application
itself, and that an unmatched window is quarantined.
They also found three defects no fake could: Hyprland's IPC directory is mode
0700 so the broker could not reach either socket and degraded silently, a broker
restart deleted the driver's socket out from under it, and input:follow_mouse=0
sends pointer events only to the keyboard-focused window, so an aimed click
reaches a client that reports nothing.
The contract bump added Monitor.id and nobody implemented it: slice B predates
v2, so the integration slice had to join a client to its output through
Workspace.monitor instead. Field added, parsed from `monitors -j`, and -1 when a
reply omits it -- a missing id must not default to 0, which would silently bind
every such client to the first output.
Two tests: the id is parsed, and omitting it yields -1.
The four modules built against the frozen contract finally have a caller. Record
schema 3 with migration, container lifecycle (create on start, teardown on kill,
reap, gc and unprompted exit, reconcile at start-up), the pointer verbs over the
lease with a 1s expiry sweep, quarantine_argv, and the new wire verbs and error
codes.
Its own report is explicit that the fake compositor proves the broker's half
only; whether Hyprland accepts these commands is the VM checks' question.
The check took ../tests/unit alone, so the broker's, the pointer driver's and the
sessions suites were collected by no check at all -- 432 of 551 tests ran only
when someone happened to enter the dev shell. It now takes ../tests, which
surfaced two real defects in the harness rather than in the code:
- tests/sessions/integration/test_lifecycle.py locates the repository by looking
upward for a pyproject.toml, which a build has no reason to contain; it raised
at import and took the whole run down as a collection error. The check now
copies the marker in, which is what the test documents it needs.
- That file also REPLACED PYTHONPATH for the daemon it spawns instead of
prepending to it. In a checkout src/ is the package, so it worked; under a
build it discarded the package under test, and 'python -m hhstreamd' died at
startup with an ImportError -- reported as a daemon failure on every test in
the file. Prepending is the fix, and the right behaviour anywhere.
pywayland joins the test environment because the pointer driver imports it.
unit: 551 collected, 550 passed, 1 skipped (a deliberate skip).
Slice A renamed the runtime directory in the module, but the old path was still
live in the code and checks it does not own, so the VM gates pointed at a
directory the module no longer creates. This moves the 21 remaining live
occurrences (client/server defaults, the unit tests that pin them, all three VM
checks, the diagnostics script, both READMEs) and deliberately leaves the three
mentions that are history rather than configuration: the plan's problem
statement, module.nix's note about the previous name, and cli.py's explanation
for spelling its default out.
Also here: docs/CONTRACT-sessions.md is now v2 with every gap the four slices
reported resolved as a decision (Monitor.id, stable_id, pid -1, Event.data,
mark(), the quarantine argv type, the corrected wlr XML path, and the state
dir/frame socket rows), and docs/CONTRACT.md is v2 because its documented socket
default moved -- wire format unchanged.
Two comments that stated the old, wrong diagnosis (a 'misnamed' IPC socket) now
state the measured one: the event socket did not fit in sun_path.
The union of main and the four slices cannot be collected by pytest: an
import-file-mismatch on test_protocol.py (the frame wire's, the broker's) and
test_server.py (the frame server's, the pointer driver's). Per-directory runs
never hit it, so this is what the union run is for.
The tempting fix is --import-mode=importlib, and it is wrong: importlib does not
put a test file's directory on sys.path, which the slices' tests rely on for
sibling imports (from conftest import HANG, from test_ops import RecordingSink).
That trades a collection error for an ImportError. Renaming the two colliding
modules keeps the import behaviour and fixes the actual problem:
tests/pointer/test_server.py -> test_pointer_server.py
tests/sessions/unit/test_protocol.py -> test_broker_protocol.py
tests: 551 passed.
Built in an independent worktree against docs/CONTRACT-sessions.md. Reports its
own slice's verification in its final message; the parent re-runs the union.
Built in an independent worktree against docs/CONTRACT-sessions.md. Reports its
own slice's verification in its final message; the parent re-runs the union.
Built in an independent worktree against docs/CONTRACT-sessions.md. Reports its
own slice's verification in its final message; the parent re-runs the union.
Built in an independent worktree against docs/CONTRACT-sessions.md. Reports its
own slice's verification in its final message; the parent re-runs the union.
The plan is the researched design (one compositor, one output+workspace per
session, serialised output-bound pointer input under a lease). The contract is
the freeze point for a parallel build: file ownership per slice, the exact
Python seams, the wire format, and the names and paths nobody may invent.
Kept separate from docs/CONTRACT.md, which governs the frame socket and is
untouched by this work.
Adding the broker's state directory as a second assignment to
systemd.tmpfiles.settings does not evaluate at all (the option takes one
definition), which broke every check that enables sessions. Both reasons to
write a tmpfiles entry now live in one lib.mkMerge.
The unit used systemd's StateDirectory=, which can only ever mean
/var/lib/<name> — on this kind of machine that is the disposable root. The
records the broker adopts and events.jsonl, the audit trail of every accepted
command, are precisely the things that should outlive a reinstall, so they are
now an option (`sessions.stateDir`) and the directory is declared with tmpfiles
so its owner and mode are still declarative.
M0 of the sessions design, wired into the flake and gated by a real check.
What is here now:
- `src/hhstreamd/` — the broker: session registry, lifecycle verbs, process-group
teardown, app allowlist, audit log, idle reaper on CLOCK_BOOTTIME.
- `src/hhstream_session/` — the CLI handlers, registered into the one front door.
- `src/hhstream/cli.py` — `hhstream status|shot|run|record|session …`, so the
frame verbs and the session namespace are one binary.
- `nix/module.nix` — `sessions.*` options and the `hhstream-sessions.service`
unit: the operator's own account (never a service account, because launched
applications should see that account's home), the compositor's group as a
supplementary group (without it a launched GUI client cannot open the Wayland
socket), the generated app allowlist, and `--compositor-runtime-dir` so
applications are handed the compositor's session rather than the broker's.
- `checks/vm-sessions.nix` — 18 subtests on a real compositor in a VM.
Two bugs found by driving it, both fixed:
- BUG-01: launched applications could not reach the compositor at all — the
broker spawned them with its own inherited environment, which names the login
session. `hhstreamd/compositor.py` discovers the socket and builds the child
environment; a directory with no usable socket is a startup refusal, not a
warning.
- BUG-02: `kill` refused to signal a live application and said nothing was
wrong. The identity gate hashed `/proc/<pid>/cmdline`, which every `execve`
replaces — and on NixOS applications are reached through wrapper scripts that
do exactly that. The gate now rests on `starttime` (+ boot id, + session id
where it is immutable) and records command-line drift as evidence of nothing.
KillMode=process is set on the unit on purpose: the default control-group kill
would take the applications down with the broker, which would make adoption and
a broker restart pointless.
There are two `sg` on this box: the setuid wrapper in /run/wrappers/bin and a
plain symlink to shadow's sg in the system profile. A login shell has the
wrapper first and works; a cron job's PATH reaches the plain one, which cannot
switch groups and dies with "setgroups: Operation not permitted" — which reads
as "chromium exited immediately" once a consumer discards its stderr. The
helper now looks for a setuid `sg` explicitly and says so if there is none.
One front door to the headless session, for reuse by any consumer: it
discovers whichever wayland-N socket exists, re-execs itself under
sg hhstream when the login predates the group membership, and encodes
recordings at the measured frame rate so clips play at true speed.